Sunday, April 02, 2006

17th CD--THE INMATES CAN RUN THE ASYLUM, BUT ONLY FOR A SHORT WHILE

Well, Well, There’s an opening for the Job Description "Congressman, 17th District."

The nice folks up in Rock Island County are accustomed to having things their own way when it comes to selecting congresspersons. Election in and election out, they’re the 600 Pound Gorilla.

This time, there ‘s a little uncertainty in the process. First, the vote will be by committeemen. For a number of reasons, the peasant counties are considering an uprising. Adams and Knox Counties have some higher than usual primary totals. The math for Counties like Adams, Knox, Christian and even Macoupin could work out. The general concept is "If we don’t hang together, we’re certain to hang separately." They have plausible candidates, Sullivan, Scholz, Mangieri among them. Our friends in Rock Island County are, to say the least, not all reading off of the same page of the hymnal.

People will tell plausible candidates it’s an opportunity. It looks like an opportunity. It sounds like an opportunity For the peasant counties’ principle wish list candidates, Sullivan and Scholz, it is an opportunity all right, an opportunity to get their lives good and screwed up.

You say, "How?" I thought you’d never ask. If the "minor" counties hold together for one candidate, they could nominate their man. Either man would beat the famously tone deaf Zinga like a pawn shop drum. He would take office in December of ’06 as a freshman congressman, likely still a member of the minority party. Committee assignments would not look like Lane’s, probably agriculture and belly button lint research.
In the meantime, having their congressman shoplifted out of their county would comprehensively piss the nice folks in Rock Island off. They would unite behind a single primary candidate and in March ’08, a presidential primary year, probably turn out 30,000 primary voters, consigning the "out" county incumbent to about 9 months of lame duckness. At least it's a long time to pack his stuff.

What’s that you say? Our brothers and sisters in Rocky wouldn’t do that? Surely you jest! Not only would they, but they’d be stupid not to do it. They would once again assert control over "their" seat in Congress and turn the dissident Counties’ Chairs into the voice of sweet reason for all future party dealings. As I said, they’d be stupid not to do it. Revenge of the 600 pound Gorilla would not occur with surgical precision. There’d be collateral damage. There wouldn’t be enough lifeboats to hold all the friends of the "successful" nominee from ’06.

As a consequence of that, these "out" county candidates have to decide whether they would like a two year victory lap as a freshman congressman enough to face almost a certain career disruption. That’s the going price for being a game piece in this exciting, Real World, board game.

So the "out" county inmates really can run the asylum and nominate a congressman but there will be hell to pay for it and the price will be paid by the "out" county nominee.

Oh, and all that fun is before we even talk about redistricting in ’12. Does anybody really think this boomerang district remains after we lose another seat or two in the decennial census of ‘10?
So, to those guys who are being pumped up by other politicians to "run" for this seat, remember the question Inspector Harry Callahan asked the armed robber "Do you feel lucky…?" For this to be a good deal, you’d have to damned lucky.

8 Comments:

At 5:19 PM, April 02, 2006, Anonymous Anonymous said...

So why is the Adams County Chairman Verne “Kingmaker” Hagstrom making phone call to other county chairman wanting them to back Sullivan for Lane’s job and appoint Scholz for the State Senate seat? Wouldn’t this be a mess, Sullivan having opposition in the next primary and Scholz losing the State Senate seat? Has Sullivan said he was willing to move? Does anyone think Scholz could win the next election? We would really be playing with a seat we tried to win for over twenty years. I can’t imagine Emil Jones wanting to gamble with losing this seat. They didn’t think it could be won by a Democrat and will do everything to protect it. The Congressman seat is up for re-election every two years, raising campaign funds for a race every two years is a challenge. Phil Hare has been with Lane since the beginning, he is electable, he knows how to play the game, union friendly and known all over the 17th Dist. Lane wants him as his replacement because he knows Phil has the same believes and will continue to work for the same things he has. Is what the “Kingmaker” going to cause problems for Adams County with the state candidates in the upcoming election?

 
At 6:31 PM, April 02, 2006, Blogger UMRBlog said...

Anon 719

My point of view in the underlying post was empathy for the candidate being pressured to make this race for the "Out" counties.

While VWH's choice of language was a bit unfortunate, he is doing what a Chairman should do, trying to assert power for his and comparable counties. He would be remiss if he didn't test the boundaries. When he said what the said, the players were not well defined. I think he deserves some slack on taking a hard line to begin with. Old Greek proverb, "You don't ask, you don't get."

Emil or no Emil, John S. gets to decide what to do with his life. I just think it would be a personal decision he would regret but I defend his right to make it.

Defending a primary in '08 would be a mess. I think I've already been pretty clear about how I feel in general about incumbents getting primary opponents. But I fancy myself a pretty good reader of demographic stats. Really hard primary race for someone from this part of the district.

I have nothing bad to say about Phil --in fact I just defended him on Arch Pundit today--but there are plenty of talented dems in Rock Island County. I will say this much. Against someone with no connection to Lane, Wicked Witch of North, Version 2.0, has no campaign. She runs against stuff, stands for nothing. In some ways, she's Mark Baker Empty Suit, Version 5.0. Why give her an issue? That's the argument against Phil and Jerry. Let her flail against imagined sins and just be her pitiful, negative self.

So I take no position on the right guy, or gal, despite my admiration for all of the players.

I disagree that K/M has done any harm here with the State Candidates or otherwise. There are forces way above his paygrade involved in this exercise. He is, so far, just doing what he's supposed to do. Now, there comes a time when you gotta know when to fold 'em and know when to hold 'em. He's not there yet.

Thanks for coming by.

 
At 6:05 AM, April 03, 2006, Anonymous Anonymous said...

On the flip side of your original argument. Rock Island has to be careful how they handle the smaller counties. A Rock Island Democrat in 08 is not a shoe-in. Lane would typically win by 3000 votes. Thats not a lot district wide. If they try to stand on the smaller counties they may create some resentment from them.

 
At 6:50 AM, April 03, 2006, Blogger UMRBlog said...

Anon 805

I take your comment to refer to the General Election impact of "600 Pound Gorilla" primary, the outcome of which is a foregone conclusion.

Therer is something to what you say but a hypothetical Boland or Jacobs runs at least with the district ambient party background, which would be more like 8000 votes, so Rocky really wouldn't fear a little, for example, civil disobedience in Macoupin.

Lane has been underrunning the ambient party persuasion of the district for some time which makes the district look more plausible for the odd empty suit/blouse.

Besides, the odd rank and file aren't really likely to walk off in the General, especially not for Zinga. Knox may be the exception there but that could be sustained.

You make a fair point but it is Mutually Assured Destruction. Also, this would be an entirely different calculation if Mowen had become the nominee.

Thank you for coming by.

 
At 6:52 AM, April 03, 2006, Blogger UMRBlog said...

I really do know how to spell "there". Fat fingers this morning.

Ben Hogan said he wouldn't practice when his fingers felt fat or the wind was blowing from the left. That is relevant to anything. I just happened to remember it.

 
At 4:31 PM, April 03, 2006, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hey 7:19
WHo do you think could beat Scholz in the senate seat? Quincy is 35 pecent of the district. Scholz will dominate in Quincy. A large portion of the district is in Scholzs media market and he has always polled very high in that market. The candidate that would win the 47th would most likely have to carry Quincy. That will not happen. You need a clue 7:19. we keep the senate seat and trade Lane for Sullivan I think taht is pretty good for progressive democrats.

 
At 6:39 PM, April 03, 2006, Blogger UMRBlog said...

Anon 631

Short term I agree with you. Longer term, party politics could eat Sullivan. It would be a great loss to see John out of public service.

Thank you for coming by

 
At 7:19 AM, April 04, 2006, Anonymous Anonymous said...

umrblog,
I see your concern for John losing the primary. However Maybe if you were on the inside you might have more perspective. What if the downstate cand. had the support of two key Quad City pols(maybe Johnston and Big Denny)?? If this were the case maybe the primary in 2008 would be a litle easier or none at all? Curious to hear your respected opinion. On another note did you not report that Teddy Brumsvold was the candidate here on your blog? Again curious what happened on that?

 

Post a Comment

<< Home